Behind the Curtain: How Game Reviews Get Rigged

Behind the Curtain: How Game Reviews Get Rigged

It's not often that you stumble upon an industry secret so juicy it could give Tony Soprano a run for his money. But here we are, peeling back the curtain

XLinkedInEmail
A colorful neon sign illuminating the word 'PINBALL' against a dark background, capturing a retro nightlife vibe.
Photo: David Rado / Pexels

It's not often that you stumble upon an industry secret so juicy it could give Tony Soprano a run for his money. But here we are, peeling back the curtain on how some game reviews get rigged.

You see, in the world of gaming journalism, there's a dark art known as "review inflation." It's like steroids for game scores, except instead of bulging biceps and record-breaking home runs, it's about inflating review scores to ridiculous heights.

Young men playing video games on a couch with intense focus, holding controllers.
Photo: Yan Krukau / Pexels

And guess what? It's not just limited to shady review sites or shills with questionable integrity. Even some respectable outlets are guilty of this sin.

Now you might be wondering how this affects you, dear reader. Well, besides making it harder for us to distinguish between a genuinely good game and a poorly disguised piece of crap (yes, I'm looking at you, Candy Crush), review inflation has some serious consequences.

For one, it erodes trust in the entire review process. If everyone's getting perfect scores, how do we know who to believe? And if we can't tell what's good from what's bad, why bother playing at all?

Secondly, and more importantly, review inflation hurts developers who are actually trying to make great games. They get lumped in with the crap because their scores are artificially deflated compared to the inflated nonsense that gets all the attention.

So what can we do about it? Well, first and foremost, we need more transparency in the review process. That means no more secret review scores or hidden algorithms. We need to see how games are being rated, who's doing the rating, and why they think a game deserves a particular score.

Secondly, we need to reward honesty and integrity in gaming journalism. That means supporting outlets that do things right and calling out those that don't. It means being critical consumers who question scores and reviews instead of blindly following them.

And finally, we need to remember that games are supposed to be fun. They're not supposed to be some kind of high-stakes game where only the perfect scores survive. So let's stop treating them like they are, and start playing for the love of the game again.

Now here come the FAQs:

Why do reviewers inflate scores?

It's simple: clicks and cash. Inflated scores get more attention, which means more traffic, which means more ad revenue. It's a vicious cycle that rewards dishonesty over honesty.

How can I tell if a game review is legit?

Look for transparency in the process. Can you see how the score was calculated? Who calculated it? Are there any conflicts of interest? If the answers are yes, then you're on the right track.

What can developers do to combat review inflation?

They can be transparent about their development processes and engage with their communities honestly. They can also work with outlets that prioritize honesty and integrity in their review processes.

Remember, dear reader, we're all in

Dive Deeper Into This Topic

Continue building your understanding with these articles

Why Everyone is Talking About Gaming News, and Why You Should Be Too

How Gaming News is Changing the Industry Forever (and How You Can Profit)

The Top 5 Gaming News Stories You Can't Afford to Miss This Month